Reports of Twitter's Downfall Are Highly Exaggerated
Written on
Chapter 1: The Perception of Twitter's Crisis
The narrative surrounding Twitter's alleged decline is rampant, especially among users on platforms like Mastodon and the wider Fediverse. Many claim Twitter has devolved into a hub of misinformation, hatred, and bigotry, exacerbated by Elon Musk's controversial decisions, prompting users and advertisers to abandon ship in search of safer alternatives such as Mastodon, Post, or Hive. Yet, upon visiting Twitter, one might observe that it largely resembles its former self.
I personally haven't deleted my Twitter account; however, I've removed the app and refrained from posting or interacting since November 17. Occasionally, I check in to gauge the state of affairs, and I'm met with the same faces, engaging in the same discussions as before. No substantial shifts seem evident. Interestingly, many individuals I frequently encounter on Mastodon continue to post there as well, albeit with different content.
In a conversation with my business partner, who also serves as the President of our agency, we touched on Musk's acquisition of Twitter. He sought my perspective, leading me to mention Mastodon and the complexities of the Fediverse, a concept he was unfamiliar with, having only a LinkedIn presence. His old-school approach to social media meant he hadn't even heard of it.
Section 1.1: The Future of Social Platforms
As we contemplate the future of federated, decentralized systems, we must abandon the notion that a single platform is desirable or even feasible. Multiple platforms will emerge, driven by advertisers seeking to connect with audiences. They will financially support whatever platform garners attention, ensuring people gravitate towards it, regardless of the circumstances—it's simply how the ecosystem operates.
From the outset, I've frequently heard the sentiment that no one wishes Mastodon to replicate Twitter, and that's a positive perspective because it’s an unattainable goal. While there may always be a demand for a public space for interaction and idea exchange, this need often conflicts with corporate interests aimed at reaching consumers. And that’s perfectly acceptable.
Subsection 1.1.1: The Emergence of New Platforms
We shouldn't be surprised when an entrepreneur creates the next big sensation that attracts users due to its robust funding and appealing features. Although platforms like Reddit and Discourse have long existed, they remain unfriendly to average users, having been designed by tech-savvy individuals. My 80-year-old mother certainly wouldn’t engage, nor would my 64-year-old business partner.
The challenge with open-source platforms lies in their lack of a unified focus on user experience. They can resemble a DIY computer assembly project, appealing only to those who enjoy such activities. Most individuals, however, prefer to be entertained, distracted, and informed. The reality is many people tend to follow the crowd, resembling sheep in search of a shepherd.
Section 1.2: The Viability of the Fediverse
Mastodon and the Fediverse seem to have reached a level of growth that suggests a sustainable community. However, it’s doubtful they will ever serve as a true public forum due to significant barriers preventing widespread participation. Instead, they resemble a coffee shop or private club, which is perfectly fine, but it doesn't fulfill all societal needs.
Nor should it.
Chapter 2: Understanding the Landscape of Social Media
The first video, "The reports of my death are greatly exaggerated!" by Mark Twain, sheds light on the misconceptions surrounding platforms like Twitter, emphasizing the resilience of established social media despite negative narratives.
The second video, "The Reports of My Death are Greatly Exaggerated," further explores the ongoing discussions about Twitter's status and the broader implications for social media.