Chapter 1: The Nature of Judgment

When we encounter new people, it's almost instinctive to form opinions about them. You might catch yourself observing someone's questionable behavior or even giving them a disapproving look. And then, there’s that moment when a teenager with bright hair challenges you with, “What’re you looking at?” In response, you could confidently declare, “I’m judging you.” The truth is, we all engage in judgment—it's a natural human tendency.

It's essential to recognize that judging others doesn't automatically make you a snob or a bad person. Research suggests that our judgments often stem from a survival instinct. At a fundamental level, we subconsciously ask ourselves: "Can I trust this individual?" and "Do I respect them?" These questions are crucial, especially in life-threatening situations, and our evolution has ingrained this instinct in us.

Our brains are designed to make quick judgments to conserve mental energy. Imagine the fatigue of analyzing every interaction in detail; it would be exhausting, even just trying to order coffee! Instead, we reserve that deep thinking for more significant issues, such as workplace conflicts or friend dynamics.

By leveraging our judgmental instincts, we can enhance our decision-making and contribute positively to society. Judgments can serve as a form of social cohesion, ensuring that we adhere to shared values and principles. This isn't about suppressing individual freedoms or looking down on others; it's about fostering mutual understanding to improve our collective existence.

Consider this: regardless of our differences—appearance, beliefs, or background—our human experiences are interconnected. We all rely on others, seek social bonds, and face life’s inevitable challenges. Judgment, therefore, can be a collective tool for wisdom, allowing us to address wrongs and strive for justice. It can drive societal progress and align us with our moral compass.

Shame, often dismissed, plays a crucial role here. It's our internal guide, alerting us when we stray from what’s right. Everyone has experienced moments where, in the midst of a poor decision, a voice in their head urges them to reconsider. That voice is shame, a protective mechanism guiding us toward better choices.

Reflecting on my own experiences, I've often felt indifferent to others' opinions. While this quality has its perks, it often developed as a defense against a challenging upbringing. I recall being a rebellious teen, boldly confronting judgment from others. In hindsight, perhaps caring more about others' perceptions could have prevented some of my reckless choices.

As we navigate our lives, it’s crucial to acknowledge that judgment is a universal experience. Rather than deny it, we should embrace this reality. However, be prepared for reciprocal judgments; when you voice your concerns about someone, they're likely to respond in kind.

Conversely, if you’re confident in your actions and they stir controversy, don’t shy away from your beliefs. Living authentically, backed by sound reasoning, reflects integrity. This commitment to authenticity leads us to a broader social consciousness—an awareness of our shared identity and the importance of community ties.

This social consciousness often fuels movements aimed at rectifying societal wrongs. Together, we can challenge harmful practices and advocate for equality across various fronts—be it gender, race, or religion. History is replete with social movements, such as:

• Women’s Suffrage
• Civil Rights Movement
• LGBTQ+ Rights Movement
• Mothers Against Drunk Driving
• Occupy Wall Street

Less widely recognized movements also exist, like Effective Altruism and the Brights Movement, all propelled by individuals who acted upon their judgments.

In summary, the next time you sense someone scrutinizing you, consider offering a nod of acknowledgment. If you live your life with integrity, their judgment should hold little weight. Yet, it’s possible that their gaze could spark a movement, promoting positive change in our world. Judging others doesn’t have to carry a negative connotation—when directed with purpose, it can facilitate meaningful progress.

Thank you for taking the time to read this! Explore more insightful content on Illumination, and if you feel inspired, share your voice by joining us as a writer. Your contributions are always welcome!

Chapter 2: Exploring Judgmental Perspectives

The first video, "How Judgmental Are You?" delves into our inherent tendency to judge, exploring its implications and potential benefits.

In the second video, "Are You JUDGY? Philip Yancey," the discussion focuses on the nuances of judgment and how it shapes our perceptions and interactions.