# Navigating the M1 Mac Studio Choices: M1 Max vs. M1 Ultra
Written on
Chapter 1: The Apple Dilemma
Apple has a knack for complicating the buying process. With each new product launch, excitement quickly morphs into confusion regarding which model to choose. This phenomenon isn't limited to one product; it extends across Apple's entire range—from dissecting the differences between the iPad Air and 11" iPad Pro to debating the best color for an iMac. It's a journey fraught with challenges.
Then comes the Mac Studio, adding another layer of complexity. This innovative platform presents two options based on the chip you select: the M1 Max, widely recognized from the MacBook Pro, and the M1 Ultra, known for its impressive capabilities. The disparity in both price and specifications between the two raises a critical question: Which one is more suited to your needs?
In the first video, "The Truth about the M1 Mac Studio | Long Term Review," the host dives into the long-term performance of the M1 Mac Studio, providing insights into the practical implications of choosing between the M1 Max and M1 Ultra.
Section 1.1: Understanding Your Needs
If you're in the market for a Mac Studio, it's likely intended for your professional or creative work. Therefore, it’s crucial to ensure that your investment yields substantial returns. Many buyers, whether they are individuals or businesses, seek maximum power from Apple’s offerings while being mindful of their financial outlay.
Pricing Overview
The pricing discussed here is in GBP, though it can often be converted directly to USD. The M1 Max Mac Studio starts at £1,999, which includes a 10-core CPU, a 24-core GPU, 32GB of unified memory, and a 512GB SSD. As you customize the machine, prices can escalate quickly. For instance, upgrading the GPU to 32 cores costs an additional £200, while increasing memory to 64GB will set you back another £400. Opting for both upgrades brings the total to £2,599. Storage also presents a range of options, with 1TB costing an extra £200 and maxing out to 8TB for a staggering £2,400. Ultimately, a fully upgraded M1 Max Mac Studio could reach £4,999.
In contrast, the M1 Ultra Mac Studio kicks off at £3,999. For this £2,000 increase, you receive a 20-core CPU, a 48-core GPU, 64GB of unified memory, and 1TB of storage. Further enhancements, like boosting the GPU cores to 64, add another £1,000, while increasing memory to 128GB will cost you an additional £800. A fully spec’d M1 Ultra can total £7,999.
Section 1.2: Performance Comparison
The computing power offered by the M1 Ultra chip is designed for a niche audience. Most users will likely recognize whether they require this high level of performance due to the specialized nature of its applications. In terms of raw capabilities, the M1 Ultra is essentially two M1 Max chips combined, effectively doubling the cores, memory bandwidth, and video encode engines.
Apple's tests indicate that the M1 Ultra outperforms the top-spec 27-inch Intel iMac by 5.3 times during intensive tasks and 2.5 times faster in specific Photoshop operations. The M1 Max, in comparison, shows a performance increase of 2.7 times and 2.2 times, respectively. This highlights a diminishing return on investment unless you're engaged in highly computational tasks where time equals money.
The second video, "NEW Mac Studio vs M1 Max MacBook Pro - Portability vs Power," provides a side-by-side analysis of the Mac Studio and M1 Max MacBook Pro, focusing on their respective strengths and weaknesses.
Chapter 2: Video and Memory Considerations
When evaluating video capabilities, the distinctions between the M1 Max and M1 Ultra are particularly compelling. The M1 Max features 32 GPU cores, while the M1 Ultra boasts 64. This translates to a higher concurrent 8K ProRes playback capability: nine streams for the M1 Max compared to eighteen for the M1 Ultra. Both versions support up to five displays, appealing to those who desire an expansive workspace.
In rendering tests with Final Cut Pro, the M1 Ultra delivers 8K footage five times quicker than a 27-inch iMac equipped with the Radeon Pro 5700 XT, whereas the M1 Max achieves a speed increase of 3.5 times. If your work involves high-stakes rendering where every second counts, the M1 Ultra may be worth the investment. However, for those uncertain about the necessity of such capabilities, the M1 Max remains a prudent choice.
Unified Memory Efficiency
Today’s Macs utilize a unified memory architecture that enhances performance by allowing the chip to access data without the need for multiple memory pools. This system means you may not require as much memory as with older Intel models. Both the M1 Max and M1 Ultra can be configured with significant amounts of memory—64GB and 128GB, respectively. If your work demands 128GB, you’ll likely be aware of it, making the M1 Ultra the right choice for your needs.
Final Thoughts on M1 Max vs. M1 Ultra
The key takeaway from this guide is that most users who genuinely need the M1 Ultra likely already recognize that requirement. If there’s any doubt, the M1 Max Mac Studio is the more suitable option. For those with a reasonable budget, consider investing more in memory and storage rather than splurging on the M1 Ultra. For everyday tasks, both chips exhibit similar single-core performance, and the benefits of added power become apparent only when utilizing extra cores, with time savings translating directly into financial value.
In fact, I’m confident that around 95% of readers will find themselves perfectly suited to the M1 Max Mac Studio bracket.
Before You Go
Join my behind-the-scenes mailing list! If you appreciate my writing, there's much more to explore on Medium. As a paying member, I highly recommend joining. Click here to support my work!