A Better Perspective on Customer Grievances

In the past, unhappy customers had limited avenues for expressing their discontent, often just venting to coworkers. Nowadays, they wield a potent tool against companies that fall short: social media.

Recent findings highlighted by the Wall Street Journal reveal that the proportion of consumers taking action to settle scores with companies—whether through public shaming or direct complaints—has surged from 3% to 9% since 2020. This shift underscores a significant change in how dissatisfied customers express their frustrations online.

However, it’s crucial to note that only about 1 in 26 dissatisfied customers actually voice their concerns to businesses; the rest simply walk away. This translates to a mere 3.85% of unhappy patrons bothering to complain—an alarmingly low figure. Furthermore, some of these vocal critics may not have valid complaints but instead are driven by personal grievances unrelated to your product.

Thus, the voices of only a small fraction of genuinely unhappy customers reach you, and while their input is valuable, it isn't sufficient for making informed decisions.

NPS: A Double-Edged Sword

Introduced around two decades ago, the Net Promoter Score (NPS) has become a staple for many marketers, often posing the question, "How likely are you to recommend our product to friends?" However, like any quantitative method, it has its drawbacks.

While the ease of aggregating responses is appealing, the data it provides often lacks depth. Respondents are typically limited to binary answers, which don’t allow for nuanced feedback like, "I’d recommend your product, but..." Even if a large percentage of respondents express dissatisfaction, the reasons behind their sentiments remain obscured.

Leveraging Happy Customers for Insights

Peter Drucker once stated, "Results are obtained by exploiting opportunities, not by solving problems." While negative feedback can highlight pain points, insights from satisfied customers are often far more beneficial.

For example, if you sell sunglasses, content customers might praise your store's location, your diverse product selection, or your user-friendly website. This positive feedback can guide improvements and innovations beyond merely correcting issues.

The Limitations of Customer Feedback in Innovation

Picture yourself as the CEO of a traditional car manufacturer facing customer complaints about uncomfortable seats and noisy engines. While addressing these issues is important, focusing solely on them may blind you to emerging competitors like Tesla or BYD.

Henry Ford famously noted that if he had asked customers what they wanted, they would have requested a faster horse. This illustrates a critical point about innovation: customers may express needs in ways that mask their true desires. A skilled marketer recognizes that the underlying need is for speed, not just a specific mode of transportation. Ford inadvertently fulfilled this need by creating a revolutionary product that met customer desires for faster travel.

Thus, limiting feedback collection to just complaints can obscure crucial insights for innovation.

A New Approach to Customer Engagement

As promised, there is a more effective strategy, both simple and intricate. We must engage with our customers directly.

Rather than relying on impersonal surveys and questionnaires, we should step out of our offices, meet customers face-to-face, share a coffee, and ask them a multitude of questions.

Avoid self-centered queries like "Do you like my product?" Instead, explore their experiences—what emotions they feel when they encounter your product, their purchasing motivations, how they use it, and what problems they aim to solve with it.

Gathering feedback from all types of customers—satisfied, dissatisfied, and even those who chose not to purchase—will lead to richer insights. The broader the range of data collected, the more refined your product offerings will become.

Join our community of strategic thinkers by subscribing to my newsletter for exclusive articles.